AI May Not Eliminate Managers. It May Change What Managers Are For.
One of the most persistent predictions about artificial intelligence is that better algorithms will reduce the need for managers. If software can monitor performance, forecast demand, schedule work, and automate routine analysis, why maintain as many layers of supervision?
New research suggests the organizational response may move in the opposite direction—at least for the predictive AI technologies that spread through firms before the recent generative-AI boom.
In “Artificial Intelligence Adoption and the Demand for Managerial Expertise,” a 2026 Strategic Management Journal study by Liudmila Alekseeva, José Azar, Mireia Giné, and Sampsa Samila, firms with greater AI adoption posted more managerial vacancies and a higher share of managerial jobs. At the same time, the skills sought in managers shifted away from routine administration and toward coordination, creativity, stakeholder management, and growth.
The Research
The researchers construct a large U.S. firm-year panel from 2010 through 2022 by linking Lightcast online job postings with Compustat financial data.
They measure firm-level AI adoption based on the share of job postings requiring AI-related skills such as machine learning. They then examine both the number and share of managerial vacancies and the specific skills listed in managerial job postings.
The study uses firm fixed-effects models and an instrumental-variable design based on firms’ historical occupational mix and later national AI-adoption patterns. The authors note that they cannot fully rule out violations of the instrument’s assumptions, so they do not present the IV estimates as definitive causal effects.
More AI Was Associated With More Managerial Hiring
The headline finding challenges a simple automation story. Firms with greater AI adoption showed greater managerial intensity.
In the instrumental-variable estimates, a one-percentage-point increase in the firm’s AI-related job-posting share was associated with a 1.2-percentage-point increase in the share of managerial postings—approximately a 7.5% increase—and about a 9% increase in managerial vacancies.
This does not mean AI cannot automate managerial tasks. The paper explicitly recognizes that monitoring, scheduling, and other codifiable activities can be automated. But new technology can simultaneously create coordination needs, new business opportunities, and organizational complexity that increase demand for people in formal managerial roles.
The Relationship Was Strongest in Manufacturing and Innovative Firms
The association between AI adoption and managerial demand was not uniform.
It was strongest in manufacturing and among firms with higher research-and-development intensity. Those settings can involve greater operational interdependence, innovation, and reconfiguration as AI is introduced.
The relationship was weaker among larger firms and firms with more codified digital routines. The results therefore point to organizational context as an important part of the AI-management relationship.
Managerial Work Shifted Away From Routine Administration
The study finds that AI adoption changes not only how many managers firms seek but also what they expect those managers to do.
Greater AI adoption was associated with lower demand for routine administrative skills such as budgeting, planning, staff management, and customer service.
This is consistent with AI taking over or reducing the burden of predictable information-processing and administrative tasks.
Interpersonal and Growth Skills Became More Important
At the same time, AI-intensive firms placed greater emphasis on capabilities such as stakeholder management, creativity, sales management, and other growth-oriented skills.
The pattern suggests a reconfiguration of managerial work. As analytical and routine tasks become more automated, managers may spend relatively more effort coordinating people and systems, integrating activities, adapting the organization, and turning new technology into growth.
The authors describe this as a shift toward capabilities that facilitate scaling, coordination, and adaptation in AI-enabled environments.
This Study Is Primarily About Predictive AI
An important caveat is timing. The data run from 2010 through 2022 and primarily capture predictive AI—machine learning, computer vision, natural-language processing, and related systems used for classification, forecasting, and optimization.
The authors explicitly caution that generative and agentic AI can automate or reshape communication, synthesis, and decision-making in different ways. The findings therefore provide a foundation for understanding AI-driven organizational change, not a definitive forecast of managerial employment under the newest AI systems.
What Leaders Should Do Differently
- Redesign roles instead of assuming headcount reduction: An AI initiative should not begin with the assumption that automating managerial tasks automatically eliminates managerial roles. The evidence suggests firms may need more coordination and adaptation as AI capabilities expand.
- Identify which management tasks are becoming less valuable: Budgeting, planning, routine staff administration, and similar codifiable activities may become relatively less central. Organizations can use that shift to redefine how managerial time is spent.
- Invest in human skills that complement AI: Stakeholder management, creativity, sales, coordination, and growth-oriented capabilities become more prominent in the study’s AI-intensive firms. Training and hiring systems may need to reflect that changing skill mix.
- Expect the organizational impact to differ by context: Manufacturing and R&D-intensive firms showed especially strong relationships. Managers should assess how operational complexity, innovation intensity, and existing digital routines affect their own organizational needs.
The Takeaway
AI does not simply substitute for management. Alekseeva, Azar, Giné, and Samila’s evidence suggests that it can change the bundle of tasks that defines management—and potentially increase demand for people who can coordinate, adapt, and scale an AI-enabled organization.
The strategic question is therefore not only, “Which managerial tasks can AI automate?” It is, “Once AI performs those tasks, what new coordination and growth work becomes more important for our managers to do?”
Topics
Human Resources
Organizations
Strategy Process
Innovation
Big Six Questions in Strategic Management
About the Authors
Liudmila Alekseeva is an Assistant Professor of Entrepreneurship in the Department of Management, Strategy and Innovation at KU Leuven’s Faculty of Economics and Business. José Azar is an Associate Professor in the School of Economics and Business at the University of Navarra. Mireia Giné is Professor of Financial Management and Head of the Financial Management Department at IESE Business School. Sampsa Samila is Professor of Strategic Management at IESE Business School.





