A Founding Partner Can Be an Asset—and a Liability—for Decades
Founders often choose powerful partners for what those relationships can provide immediately: expertise, legitimacy, resources, access, or credibility.
But a founding relationship can outlive the relationship itself. It can become embedded inside the organization—and in the minds of outside stakeholders—for decades.
A 2026 Strategic Management Journal study of South American airlines shows why that matters. The same founding partner can leave two different legacies: one that strengthens the organization internally and another that constrains how outsiders perceive it.
In “From armed roots to airline routes in South America: A dual imprinting perspective,” Kunyuan Qiao, Shon R. Hiatt, and Wesley D. Sine study airlines founded across 10 South American countries from the industry’s beginnings in 1919 through 1984.
Their central insight is that founding relationships can leave both an internal capability imprint and an external identity imprint—and those two imprints can have opposite strategic consequences.
The Research
The study examines South American airlines with and without military involvement during their founding period. In early commercial aviation, military organizations often possessed valuable aviation expertise, disciplined operating routines, safety practices, and technical knowledge.
At the same time, a visible military association could affect how foreign governments and regulators categorized an airline, particularly when aviation was viewed through a national-security lens.
The authors analyze how these two pathways influenced international route expansion and how the effects changed as the broader political and institutional environment evolved.
The Internal Imprint: Capability
Military founding partners could provide airlines with operational procedures, safety routines, technical expertise, and organizational discipline that became embedded in the firm.
These capabilities helped airlines operate more effectively and supported international expansion. Crucially, the advantage could persist even after the founding partner’s direct role diminished because routines and tacit knowledge had become part of the organization itself.
This is an important distinction for strategy. Some benefits from a partner are transactional and disappear when the relationship ends. Others are absorbed into the firm’s capabilities and continue to affect performance long afterward.
The External Imprint: Identity
The same military relationship could create a second legacy outside the organization.
Foreign regulators and other stakeholders could continue to perceive an airline through its historical military association. In politically sensitive contexts, that identity could raise national-security concerns and restrict international expansion.
The result is a strategic paradox: the partner relationship that helped build superior operating capabilities could simultaneously create an identity that made foreign market access more difficult.
Internal and External Imprints Do Not Decay the Same Way
The authors argue that internal capability imprints tend to be more durable because they are embedded in organizational structures, routines, and tacit knowledge.
External identity imprints live in stakeholder perceptions. They can persist, but they are more responsive to changes in how outside audiences interpret the original association.
That means history is not simply a fixed legacy. The strategic impact of a founding relationship can change as the partner’s own role or reputation changes.
Civilian Air Traffic Control Reduced the Capability Advantage
One post-founding change examined in the study is the transition from military to civilian air traffic control.
As aviation knowledge and practices became more broadly available outside military institutions, capabilities that had once been scarce diffused more widely. The competitive advantage associated with military-derived expertise therefore weakened.
The underlying lesson is broader than aviation: a founding partner may provide a scarce capability, but its advantage can erode if the surrounding ecosystem later makes that knowledge widely accessible.
Military Coups Intensified the Identity Disadvantage
The external identity effect moved differently.
When military coups heightened political sensitivity, foreign regulators had stronger reasons to view military-associated airlines through a security lens. Under those conditions, the negative consequences of the identity imprint became stronger.
In other words, later events involving the type of founding partner can reactivate or amplify stakeholder perceptions that were formed years earlier.
What Leaders Should Do Differently
- Evaluate partners on future identity risk, not only current value: When choosing investors, strategic partners, sponsors, board members, or government partners, founders should ask not only what the relationship provides today but also what identity the association creates for external audiences.
- Separate capability transfer from reputational dependence: Organizations should deliberately absorb useful knowledge, routines, and capabilities so that value can persist independently of the partner. At the same time, they should avoid making the organization’s public identity unnecessarily dependent on the partner’s continued reputation.
- Monitor how the partner’s environment changes: A founding relationship may appear distant historically, but later political, regulatory, or reputational changes can alter how stakeholders interpret that history.
- Plan for dual legacies: Powerful partners can create both advantages and constraints. Strategy should account for both rather than treating affiliation as uniformly positive or negative.
A Historical Context With a Broader Lesson
The empirical setting is unusual: South American airlines founded during a period when military institutions played major roles in aviation and politics. Managers should therefore be cautious about assuming the exact effects generalize mechanically to every modern partnership.
But the mechanism is broadly relevant. Venture investors, governments, universities, celebrity founders, technology platforms, and strategic corporate partners can all leave internal capabilities and external identities behind.
The Takeaway
Founding partnerships can persist in two places: inside the organization and outside it.
Qiao, Hiatt, and Sine’s study shows that military founding relationships helped create operational capabilities that supported international expansion, while also creating an external identity that could trigger security concerns and constrain that expansion.
The strategic question for founders is therefore not simply, “What can this partner give us?” It is also, “What will this relationship teach us to become—and what will it teach others to believe we are?”
Topics
Resource-based View
Stakeholder Strategy
Evolution & Change
Organizations
Big Six Questions in Strategic Management
About the Authors
Kunyuan Qiao is an Assistant Professor of International Business and Strategy at Northeastern University’s D’Amore-McKim School of Business. Shon R. Hiatt is an Associate Professor of Management and Organization at the USC Marshall School of Business. Wesley D. Sine is a Professor of Management at the Cornell SC Johnson College of Business.





